See something wrong? Every step here links to an official source, and we want it right. Send us a correction, and we'll fix it and note the change.
Two ways a building gets made
Every building goes through the Buildings Department. City law makes it illegal to build, change, tear down or change the use of a building without a Buildings Department permit, except for a short list of minor work (Administrative Code 28-105.1; exempt work rule). From there, a project takes one of two paths.
Path A, "as-of-right": the Buildings Department only. As-of-right means the project follows the zoning rules already in place for its lot. Zoning sets what a lot can be used for and how big and tall a building on it can be (Manhattan Community Board 4).
Path B: City Planning, or another city board, gets a say first. Some projects need a decision from the City Planning Commission, its Chair, or the Board of Standards and Appeals before the Buildings Department will issue permits.
Either way, the Buildings Department issues the permits. Path B adds steps before them. It doesn't replace them.
An owner wants to build
Does the project follow the zoning already in place for its lot?
Yes: Path A
- File plans with the Buildings Department
- Plan review: problems to fix, then approval
- Hire the special inspector
- PermitsPath B projects need their sign-off before this step
- Demolition, if there's an old buildingBoard is notified before a full-demolition permit
- The dig and foundationNeighbors get notices first
- Construction and inspections
- Sign-off: Certificate of Occupancy
No: Path B first
A city review before permits
- ULURP (rezonings, special permits)
- ELURP (the newer, faster review)
- A certification (like the supermarket bonus)
- A variance (Board of Standards and Appeals)
The board holds a hearing or sends comments. It's advice the city doesn't have to follow
Once it's signed off, the project joins Path A at permits
Yellow = where the community board comes in.
Every project ends up at the Buildings Department for permits. Only Path B projects get a community board review, and that review is advice.
Path A, step by step
- Hire an architect or engineer. The owner hires a licensed architect or engineer. That person, called the Applicant of Record, files everything with the Buildings Department for the owner (Working on Your Project).
- File the application and plans. The new building gets its own filing. If there's an old building to tear down first, that's a separate demolition filing (Buildings Department; demolition FAQ). Before the plans are approved, the architect or engineer lists every inspection the job will need on a form called the TR1. These "special" and "progress" inspections are checks during construction, done by inspectors registered with the city (Building Code 1704.1; TR1 instructions).
- Plan review. A Buildings Department plan examiner checks the plans against the codes and zoning, sends back objections (problems to fix), and approves once they're fixed (Obtaining a Permit). Some plans skip the examiner: under what the Department calls Professional Certification, the architect or engineer certifies their own plans (DOB NOW guide). Every week, the Department emails each community board and Council Member a list of new building applications it rejected in their area (Administrative Code 28-104.2.8).
- Hire the special inspector. Before permits, the owner hires a Special Inspection Agency, a company registered with the city to do those inspections, and tells the Department which one (Working on Your Project).
- Get permits. The contractor applies for the work permit. The Department checks the paperwork, which it says takes two business days or less (DOB NOW overview for owners).
- Staff the site. A new building, a full demolition, or a job that needs inspections for underpinning (shoring up a neighbor's foundation) or for holding up the sides of a dig must have a construction superintendent. That person has to act on unsafe conditions, up to stopping the work (Building Code 3301.13). A "major building" also needs a written site safety plan and a certified site safety manager or coordinator (Building Code 3310). For permits requested on or after Dec. 11, 2024, a major building is one that's 7 or more stories or 75 feet or taller. Before that, it was 10 stories or 125 feet (Buildings Department service notice).
- Demolition (if there's an old building), then the dig. Demolition plans, signed by an architect or engineer, must be approved before demolition starts (Building Code 3306.5). The dig follows city-approved plans for holding up the sides of the hole, called support of excavation drawings (Buildings Department excavation advisory). Both come with notices to the neighbors, covered under Neighbors.
- Inspections during construction. The special inspector checks each item listed on the TR1. If they leave the job, they file a withdrawal on that same form (TR1 instructions).
- Sign-off. After final inspections and the special inspector's sign-off on the TR1, the Department issues a new Certificate of Occupancy, the document that says how a building can legally be used, or, for some jobs, a Letter of Completion (Acquire Permits).
Path B: when City Planning gets a say
In plain words
- ULURP (the Uniform Land Use Review Procedure) is the city's public review for big decisions about what can be built where. It's written into the City Charter, with set deadlines at each stop, so neighbors, the Borough President and elected officials get a say before the city decides (City Planning).
- ELURP is a newer, faster version for smaller projects, created by voters in November 2025 (2025 Charter Revision Commission final report).
- The supermarket bonus (its official name is FRESH) is a zoning program that lets a building have extra space if it includes a qualifying grocery store (Zoning Resolution, Article VI, Chapter 3). To get it, the store has to be certified: signed off by the Chair of the City Planning Commission (Zoning Resolution 63-30).
- A variance is permission from the Board of Standards and Appeals to depart from the zoning rules (Manhattan Community Board 4).
When a project needs ULURP, and when it doesn't
A building that follows the zoning already on its lot doesn't need ULURP. Building permits aren't on the City Charter's list of ULURP actions (Charter 197-c). City Planning calls a decision that needs the City Planning Commission's judgment "discretionary" (City Planning: How Zoning Gets Amended). The ones that go through ULURP include:
- changing the zoning map (rezoning a lot or an area)
- special permits from the City Planning Commission
- changes to the City Map, like streets
- the city selling off its own property, or choosing sites for city facilities
(City Planning: How Zoning Gets Amended; City Planning ULURP page; Manhattan Community Board 4)
Changes to the zoning rules' own text aren't ULURP, but they go through a similar public review (Manhattan Community Board 4). Certifications like the supermarket bonus aren't ULURP either.
How ULURP works
City Planning first checks that the application is complete, which it calls certifying it. Then the application moves through five stops, each with a deadline (City Planning; Brooklyn Community Board 4's ULURP guide):
| Stop | Time | What it does |
| Community board | 60 days | Public hearing, then advice to the city |
| Borough President | 30 days | Advice to the city |
| City Planning Commission | 60 days | Public hearing, then a vote that decides |
| City Council | 50 days | Public hearing, then a vote that decides |
| Mayor | 5 days | Approves or vetoes |
The community board and Borough President give advice, which the city doesn't have to follow. The City Planning Commission and City Council make the actual decision, and the Council can override a mayor's veto with a two-thirds vote (2025 Charter Revision Commission final report).
What a community board "no" does. It isn't a veto. Most rezonings go to the City Council anyway (Charter 197-d(b)(1)). For a project that wouldn't otherwise go to the Council, a "no" can force a Council vote, but only if the board (after its public hearing) and the Borough President both recommend against it in writing, on time, and the Borough President then files a written objection within five days of the City Planning Commission's decision (Charter 197-d(b)(2)). A "no" doesn't raise the number of votes needed to approve. If the Commission rejects or changes a board's written recommendation, it has to explain why in writing (Charter 197-c(h)). A board's "no" only counts if it followed the rules: a public hearing, a quorum and the deadline (ULURP rules, 62 RCNY 2-03).
The other reviews
- ELURP. The community board still gets 60 days, at the same time as the Borough President. The process ends at the City Planning Commission, with no City Council vote, except for affordable housing on public land. The final ELURP rules took effect Nov. 14, 2026 (2025 Charter Revision Commission final report; ELURP rules).
- The supermarket bonus. City Planning sends the community board a copy of the application. The board has 45 days to send comments, and the Chair waits for them or for the 45 days to pass. The rule says the Chair's sign-off is "a precondition to the issuance of any building permit, including any foundation" permit. In plain words: no permits until it's signed off (Zoning Resolution 63-30).
- Other certifications. Some others go to the board too. For example, City Planning sends the board kiosk and open-air cafe applications for public plazas, and the Chair has to consider the board's opinion (Zoning Resolution 37-73).
- Variances and special permits from the Board of Standards and Appeals. The community board gets a copy within five days and has 60 days to hold an optional hearing and send a recommendation. It also gets 20 days' notice of the Board of Standards and Appeals hearing (Charter 668; Board of Standards and Appeals rules; Queens community board training, Oct. 2025).
- Landmarks. For work on a landmark or in a historic district that goes to a public hearing, the applicant presents to the community board first, and the board sends Landmarks a letter. Landmarks says "community board recommendations are not binding." Work approved by Landmarks staff skips the hearing, and the board (Landmarks presentation guidelines; Certificate of Appropriateness).
What the November 2025 ballot measures changed
None of the three Charter changes voters approved on Nov. 4, 2025 touched Buildings Department permits or the notices on this page. Question 3 created ELURP. Question 2 created a fast track for affordable housing rezonings in 12 named community districts, starting Jan. 1, 2027; in Brooklyn, those are districts 10, 12 and 18. Question 4 created an Affordable Housing Appeals Board. The changes took effect Dec. 2, 2025. The Charter Revision Commission says the measures "would not eliminate or shorten Community Board review in any instance" (ballot questions; final report; the 12 districts).
Neighbors: notices, surveys and monitoring
Whoever is doing the work has to protect the buildings next door, their footings and foundations included, for the whole job and at their own expense. If the neighbor won't let them onto the property to do that, the neighbor takes on that duty instead (Building Code 3309.4). Every rule below comes from the 2022 Building Code, Chapter 33 (PDF).
| When | What's required | Who gets it | Code section |
| The work needs access to the property next door | A letter at least 60 days before work starts: what the work is, the schedule, any inspections or monitoring planned on the neighbor's property, and the protection planned there. If there's no answer, a second letter 30 to 45 days before | Owner next door | 3309.1.1 |
| Before demolition | A letter at least 10 days before: what the work is, the schedule, and who to contact | Owners next door | 3306.3.2 |
| Before demolition | Notice 24 to 48 hours before | Buildings Department | 3306.3.1 |
| During some demolitions | Watching neighboring buildings with brick, stone or wood walls that carry their weight, under a written plan that sets how much movement is allowed and what happens if it's passed | Set by the plan | 3306.12 |
| Before a dig deeper than 10 feet, or 5 to 10 feet deep within 10 feet of a neighbor | A preconstruction survey: a record of the condition of every neighboring building before work starts | Not stated in the code | 3309.4.3 |
| Before that dig | A letter at least 10 days before: what the work is, the schedule, and who to contact | Owners next door | 3304.3.2 |
| Before any soil or foundation work | Notice 24 to 48 hours before | Buildings Department | 3304.3.1 |
| During the dig | Monitoring nearby buildings for movement (any building closer to the dig than the dig is deep), under a plan written by an architect or engineer and accepted by the Buildings Commissioner. The plan sets what's measured, how often, how much movement is allowed, and when it gets reported | Set by the plan | 3309.4.4, 3309.16 |
| If the Buildings Commissioner sees a possible hazard | Neighboring buildings measured at least every 24 hours to check for movement | Set by the order | 3309.4.5 |
What the code doesn't say: whether the preconstruction survey has to cover the inside of neighboring buildings, or that monitoring readings have to go to the Buildings Department. Each project's monitoring plan sets how readings get reported.
2625 Bedford, laid over the path
2625 Bedford was on both paths. Its permits for the dig and foundation went out Sept. 9, 2026. Its supermarket bonus application went to City Planning on Oct. 7. Facts and links are from our sources page. None of this says why 1321 Flatbush fell.
Buildings DepartmentThe siteCity PlanningCommunity Board 17
- The site
The soil report describes a ten-story building.
- Buildings Department
A zoning diagram on the building application shows three stories and eight apartments.
- Community Board 17
Community Board 17 is sent a demolition notice, by certified mail. When the board received it isn't known.
- The site
Survey rates 1321's wall facing the site "Poor," checked from the outside only.
- Buildings Department
Demolition permits issued.
- Buildings Department
Stop-work order: required overhead protection for the neighbors wasn't installed.
- Buildings Department
Dig plans approved, titled for three stories. The city's record for that filing lists nine.
- Buildings Department
Demolition found still going under the stop-work order: $10,000. The building was fully demolished by this date.
- Community Board 17
Community Board 17 is sent an excavation notice, mailed June 11. We found no general rule that requires one. What it was sent under is still being checked.
- Buildings Department
Permits for the dig and foundation issued. Digging starts the next day.
- City Planning
Supermarket bonus application submitted, describing nine stories. City Planning lists it as filed Nov. 9.
- The site
1321 Flatbush falls into the excavation. Eight people die.
The supermarket bonus rule says no building permit, foundation permits included, until the City Planning Chair signs off. At 2625 Bedford, the permits came about a month before the application. Did that rule apply here? That's a question for the city.
Step by step
| Step | 2625 Bedford's record | The question on the record |
| Applications filed | The demolition and the new building were separate filings. On the building filing, a zoning diagram (the drawing that shows how a building fits its zoning) dated Dec. 24, 2025 shows three stories and eight apartments. The city's record for the dig filing lists nine stories and 64 apartments | Three stories or nine? (The soil report said ten.) |
| Plan review | The Buildings Department flagged the demolition application for answering "No" when asked if the building next door is brick, stone or wood. The Department said the answer should be "Yes." The reply on file: "PW1 was corrected" (the PW1 is the application form) | A "Yes" can mean the neighbor has to be watched for movement during demolition (3306.12). Was a monitoring plan filed? |
| Special inspector named | MD Islam, agency 8904, was the special inspector on the dig and foundation filings. No inspection is marked "Certified," which can mean it simply hasn't been signed off yet | What do the inspection reports show? |
| Inspections listed on the TR1 | The soil report expected the buildings touching the lot line "would need underpinning" (shoring up their foundations). Neither inspection list includes underpinning | Was any done? |
| Demolition notices | Letters to Community Board 17 and the neighbors are dated Jan. 14, 2026. The Buildings Department's online system says they were created Sept. 11, 2025 | Why the gap? The record doesn't say |
| Demolition | March 20, 2026: the city ordered all demolition stopped because required overhead protection for the neighbors wasn't installed. April 23: the city found demolition still going under that order, a $10,000 penalty. The building was fully demolished by April 23 | No open question. Both penalties were admitted and paid |
| Preconstruction survey | March 5, 2026: 1321's wall facing the site rated "Poor." The survey covered only the sidewalk and outside walls, "as requested by the client." The project's own soil report and dig plans called for inspecting inside and out | Why outside only? |
| Dig notices | Letters dated June 10, 2026. The city's online system says they were created Feb. 5. The notices meant for 1321's owner were addressed to 1321 itself; the deed lists a different address for the owner | Did the owner get them? |
| Supermarket bonus | City Planning's project page lists the application as filed Nov. 9, 2026, two days before the tragedy. Dig and foundation permits were issued Sept. 9 | The rule says no building permit, foundation permits included, until the Chair signs off. Did that rule apply here? |
| Monitoring during the dig | The dig plans set their own stop-work limits, like half an inch of movement. No monitoring readings appear in any public filing | Who did the monitoring, and who saw the readings? |
| Community board | Community Board 17 was sent a demolition notice dated Jan. 14, 2026, and an excavation notice dated June 10, 2026. Its posted Land Use minutes from Feb. 2025 to Sept. 2026 don't mention 2625 Bedford. City Planning's project page still lists the supermarket bonus application as "Not yet noticed," so the board hadn't been sent its copy | What was the excavation notice sent under? Being checked |
Still to add: whether the nine-story plan made this a "major building" (7 or more stories, for permits requested on or after Dec. 11, 2024), and what that would have required on site.
How we checked
Every step on this page links to an official source: the City Charter, the Building Code, the Administrative Code, the Zoning Resolution, or a Buildings Department, City Planning, Board of Standards and Appeals or Landmarks page. Where something is still being checked, we say so, and we'll update the page when the answers come back. We're not lawyers or engineers. See something wrong? Send us a correction, and we'll fix it and note the change.
Sources
- 2022 NYC Building Code, Chapter 33: Safeguards During Construction or Demolition
- Administrative Code 28-105.1: permits required and 28-104.2.8: notification of rejection
- Buildings Department rule on work exempt from permits
- Buildings Department service notice: new definition of major building (July 8, 2024)
- Buildings Bulletin 2026-012 (July 9, 2026)
- Buildings Department document list (Oct. 2026)
- Rescinded policies: 12/87, 13/87 and the 1979 memo; Buildings Bulletins 2015-032 and 2023-021
- HPD: Community Board Notification guide; Zoning Resolution 27-161, 27-162 and 37-73
- 1 RCNY 3301-01
- Buildings Department: Obtaining a Permit, Acquire Permits, Working on Your Project, DOB NOW guide, DOB NOW overview for owners, TR1 instructions, special inspections, excavation advisory, demolition FAQ
- City Charter 197-c, 197-d and 668
- ULURP rules, 62 RCNY 2-03
- City Planning: ULURP process, How Zoning Gets Amended, project 2025K0434
- Zoning Resolution 63-30 and Article VI, Chapter 3
- 2025 Charter Revision Commission final report, ballot questions, ELURP rules, the 12 fast-track districts
- Board of Standards and Appeals rules; Queens community board training
- Landmarks: presentation guidelines, Certificate of Appropriateness
- Community board pages: Manhattan CB4, Manhattan CB4 land use, Brooklyn CB4 ULURP guide
- 2625 Bedford: The Flatbush Tragedy: What Was on the Record and the records it links